Honkai: Star Rail vs Blue Archive — Which Pity System Is Better?
The two games play differently but the question is the same: which one treats your pulls better? Here's every number side by side — rates, pity, guarantees and F2P income.
pity system comparison
| 🚂 Honkai: Star Rail | 🎓 Blue Archive | |
|---|---|---|
| Base 5★ rate | 0.6% | 3.0% |
| Soft pity starts | pull 74 | none |
| Soft pity step | +6%/pull | — |
| Hard pity | 90 pulls | 200 pulls |
| Featured guarantee | 50/50 + carry-over | no 50/50 (spark) |
| Pull cost | 160 stellar jade | 120 pyroxene |
| Avg pulls per 5★ | ~62 | ~40 |
| Worst case featured char | 180 pulls | 400 pulls |
f2p income comparison
| 🚂 Honkai: Star Rail | 🎓 Blue Archive | |
|---|---|---|
| F2P income / month | 9,900 stellar jade | 9,000 pyroxene |
| Pulls / month (F2P) | 61 | 75 |
| 5★ per month (avg) | 0.98 | 1.88 |
| F2P friendliness | ✅ winner |
F2P income = community baseline (dailies, events, endgame, free battle pass, maintenance). 5★/month uses average pulls per 5★, not hard pity — so spark-based games aren't penalized.
verdict
- Faster hard pity: Honkai: Star Rail (90 vs 200 pulls)
- Higher base rate: Blue Archive (3.0% vs 0.6%)
- More F2P pulls/month: Blue Archive (75 vs 61)
- Guarantee system: Honkai: Star Rail has a 50/50 carry-over guarantee; Honkai: Star Rail uses a spark (exchange) system instead
The bottom line: Blue Archive gives a free player more 5★ per month (1.88 vs 0.98), while Honkai: Star Rail hits hard pity sooner. Check each game's Honkai: Star Rail calculator and Blue Archive calculator for your exact numbers.
other comparisons
🌌 Genshin Impact vs 🌊 Wuthering Waves 🌌 Genshin Impact vs 🚂 Honkai: Star Rail 🌌 Genshin Impact vs 📱 Zenless Zone Zero 🌌 Genshin Impact vs 🦊 Arknights 🌌 Genshin Impact vs 🎓 Blue Archive 🚂 Honkai: Star Rail vs 🌊 Wuthering Waves 🚂 Honkai: Star Rail vs 📱 Zenless Zone Zero 🚂 Honkai: Star Rail vs 🦊 Arknights 📱 Zenless Zone Zero vs 🌊 Wuthering Waves 📱 Zenless Zone Zero vs 🦊 Arknights 📱 Zenless Zone Zero vs 🎓 Blue Archive 🌊 Wuthering Waves vs 🦊 Arknights 🌊 Wuthering Waves vs 🎓 Blue Archive 🦊 Arknights vs 🎓 Blue Archive